Trump’s popularity is still surprisingly high. How can we explain it, and what can it teach us about populism ?
Until very recently I was stunned. I just wasn’t getting it. It was such a huge mystery to me. How, how on earth could a great part of republican Americans still like Trump ? This is how I ended up thinking about it and trying to understand.
“He is a disaster and they will get it, right ?”
This is pretty much what I was thinking. He might be the worst individual that has ever been elected as President of the United States. I really don’t know all of them to be able to compare, let’s be honest, but still. I try to stay positive, I really do, but every time I find something to go his way he immediately gives me another reason to face-palm myself in despair.
Let’s try to sum up why :
- He has “inappropriate” relations with women, and this is of course an euphemism. The “grabbing” campaign revelation was stunning. It is not an isolated incident…
- Russia very probably meddled in his election…
- …and he probably knew it.
- He unilaterally blew a global warming deal that was so hard to make and yet so hopeful.
- He fired so many people already that I lost count of it.
- He tried (and failed) to rip off so many people of basic health insurance.
- He passed one of the most pro-inequalities tax reform ever made.
- He uses social networks with a disregard of global peace that is chilling.
- He is utterly childish and incredibly immature.
- An so on, and so on… this list just keep getting longer day after day.
So logically they should just get it, right ? His popularity should have dropped so deep now that he should stand on the edge of a very natural impeachment. I just have to check it and it should be a question of minutes now. Okay so let’s get a glance at the polls just to check that… no problem.
Here they are …
for more details : Updated poll on: RealClearPolitics.com
He still has near 42 % of the US voters approving him ? That much ? And he actually gained approval lately ? After a year long slow decline down to 38% he actually made it back to 42 % ?
Really ? Are you kidding me polls ? This MUST be an error.
We must find another source, and here is a very good one:
WSJ Poll ( very interesting indeed read the full article).
Well no. It is not. It is accurate. Up to 85% of republicans do approve his performance…
Despite all he did, despite all he said, despite all he is, he is still polling relatively high, and incredibly high among republicans. Well he is still one of the worst performing president according to corresponding time-in-office polls, don’t get me wrong, but… he is is still approved by 42 % of Americans and 85% of republicans. Of course those 42% and 85% are pretty much the same people, but this is disturbing, even mind-puzzling for my skewed European mind. Explanations like “they are fools”, “they are mad”, “they just don’t get it” won’t cut it this time.
We have to go deeper.
So why ? Why more than 40% of US people still like him ?
I am French and I despise him. My primal opinion of him is that he is a walking disaster for the US and the world at large. But I think I finally got a glance at an explanation. Here it is :
They are not liking him. Not really. They are disliking me.
Well not me of course, I am French so Trump supporters pretty much don’t care about me at all. I am certainly not that egocentric to think so.
But they do despise American people “like” me. To clarify my thoughts : they strongly dislike urban, kind of liberal, not especially religious and talking-way-too-much-on-social-networks people. They fell endangered in their way of life, by those people.
And that is it. They dislike other people, different people. This is all about the people. About partisanship, about backing those that you feel share your way of life, who are similar to you, who are on your side. They might call them liberals or democrats it does not really matter, they are just “the other side”.
A great part of them don’t really like Trump, but they know that those pesky liberals abhor him, and just cannot stop whining about it all day long on facebook or twitter, so he must be doing something right. The more democrats hate Trump the more they are inclined to back him.
They are not vindictive, I never said that, but they are very different, so different that it is hard to understand them because we don’t get what is important to them.
As a reminder let’s sum up who the Trump supporters are :
- They are more likely to be men.
- They are more likely to be older.
- They are more likely to be living in rural areas.
- They are more likely to be religious.
- They less likely to have a college degree.
- They have on average lower revenues.
This does not mean that they are racists, rednecks, zealots, ignorant, or even lazy. No, no at all. They are normal people with families, jobs, homes, diversity… It is just that they feel different because they live differently. Of course there are some crazy lunatics out there in those 42%, but they are a minority even in the GOP. But they are so ridiculously extremist that medias cannot help to push them forward to scare you. Like in this interview. Be careful to that.
Still, the moderate majority (GOP moderate that is relative) doesn’t have much in common with the usual democrat/liberal people and they might fear that they are somehow losing the economic game. When you are unemployed, with no tech skills and you see all the jobs vanish to be replaced by developers, digital marketing or designers jobs, you are naturally inclined to think that somehow politics are not going your way, whatever the winning side tells you.
It is therefore completely understandable for them to quietly by firmly resent people who are probably urban, with higher paying jobs, and with more adapted skills to the new economy, and who are snubbing them on their facebook wall. The very people who are trashing Trump and its supporters all day long on social networks and that always look down on them, quite literally sometime when they use the expression “fly-over states”.
And we get back to Trump. They know that you hate him, you just cannot stop telling it all around. The thing is they probably don’t really like him either but they might want to send you a message like this : “I don’t like you, I don’t like you snubbing me all the time, despising my way of life, and this is how I express it to you. The guy is a loser. We know it, we are not bad people, we are not stupid, but this is a warning call. Do something so that we can trust you again so that we can stop this non sense”.
In fact it is even possible for them to think unconsciously : “I am kind of losing the economic game here, and they are kind of wining it. So whatever they say is good, is probably not so good for me”. The materialization of the classic :
“The enemy of my enemy, is my friend”.
And this is true everywhere, so what can be done ?
So let’s sum it up to the gist of it : they don’t like the people, you who hate Trump.
And this is not only about Trump. This is the same problem with all populist waves around the world. At least two examples out of the US should be noticed : Brexit and French Front National election results.
Let’s focus on France with Marine Le Pen. Her supporters don’t really like her. She is not actually popular as a person. Her younger niece is actually more popular than her. She managed to slowly build a reassuring and somehow barely moderate image, but the popularity of her party was really brewed on the same resentment I described : good people with a rural, traditional way of life felt endangered by the various changes happening in their life, be it technology, or immigration.
So everything boils down to one thing : they don’t like us because we are different and they don’t want us to tell them what to think.
But we need to be honest here : we don’t like them either. This is going both ways don’t we dare forget that. This is both groups fault, not only this other’s. And waiting for the other side to change its mind while mocking them, insulting them and hoping that they will just say “you are right” is not really clever. So we need to change that.
And the only way to do it is to understand that the various issues we disagree on are really the emanation of a deeper problem which is : we don’t like each other and we just want to be right.
We don’t like the people, the issues are just an expression of it.
Think about it as couple therapy. Couple arguing all the time are often focusing on issues like “you never clean”, “you go out to often with your friends”, “this is not how I want to raise my children”, “you spend too much”. But what they really say is “I don’t love you anymore, and I am not sure I want to live with you”.
We focus on the issues but we forget that we cannot solve them, where compromise is inevitable, unless we trust each other.
So what can we do to try to gain back the trust. What can we unilaterally do in order to improve the situation ? A few ideas :
- We should stop trying to be clever and pretentious about it. Stop mocking the other side. The usual clever snobbish social networks remarks are not smart. They only make it worth. Be rational, be calm, be respectful. Argue smartly. Humor is always great, but mockery is not.
- Try to consider for once that a rural/conservative/republican way of life might actually be good, and that good people may actually choose it. Remember, for the great majority of them they are normal people, they are not racists, extremists or ignorant, like you are not individualist, weak and pretentious.
- Try to admit that all you care about in politics might actually be good for you, and not for other people. That technology for example might bring you a lot more good than it bring to them.
- The last one is going to sting a little : try to admit that Trump might actually have done something useful, find something because you will find it. For me this might be the Korean peace process. I must admit that should it continue this way I would be happily surprised and quite frankly I would have to admit, albeit very reluctantly :
Okay he might not be THAT bad after all.
2 thoughts on “How can they possibly still like Trump ?”
Comme tu le dis, Trump reste quand même l’un des présidents américains les plus impopulaires de l’histoire. Cela relativise sa popularité. Mais en effet, on observe dans plusieurs pays comme les USA, la France et le Royaume-uni une ligne de fracture (sociale comme disait un autre homme politique) entre le monde rural et les villes, entre les bénéficiaires de la mondialisation et les perdants, entre ceux qui s’enrichissent et ceux qui s’appauvrissent. Et ces derniers n’ont pas de message d’espoir des partis sociaux-démocrates classiques. Ils ne leur font donc pas confiance pour voir leur situation s’améliorer. Ce qui crée un vide habilement exploité par Trump, Farage et Le Pen. La visite de Marine Le Pen à l’usine de Whirlpool était d’ailleurs emblématique de sa “défense” des ouvriers comme les déplacements de Trump dans le nord-est américain en désindustrialisation, qui lui ont donné la victoire finale !
Je partage ta tolérance: rien de sert de mépriser son prochain, encore moins lorsqu’il est en difficulté. Mais ne pas comprendre pourquoi des gens “normaux” votent Trump ou Le Pen, c’est se voiler la face sur les difficultés et le sentiment d’abandon d’une partie de la population. Espérons que Macron en tienne compte!
Merci pour ta réponse Tanguy. En effet, au fond de tout cela repose le sentiment bien légitime d’une grande partie de la population de ne pas profiter de la mondialisation et des avancées technologiques.
Un point à bien prendre en considération avant de trop rapidement les juger.